“推理女王”在作品中抽絲剝繭,而自身卻是謎團(tuán)重重:三集紀(jì)錄片《阿加莎·克里斯蒂:解密懸疑女王》從阿加莎的作品入手,深入探索這位作家隱秘的熱愛(ài)、恐懼、信仰、以及她生活的動(dòng)蕩時(shí)代。 在歷史學(xué)家露西·沃斯利(Lucy Worsley)看來(lái),著名偵探小說(shuō)家阿加莎·克里斯蒂(Agatha Christie)用精心打造的公眾形象隱藏了“真實(shí)的自己”。阿加莎的生活和作品反映了20世紀(jì)的社會(huì)劇變,作為公眾人物聲名遠(yuǎn)揚(yáng),而她的真實(shí)性格卻令人難以捉摸。露西·沃斯利深挖這位偵探小說(shuō)家的相關(guān)資料與作品,試圖找到更多的線索,解開(kāi)阿加莎·克里斯蒂自身的謎團(tuán)。
看完最感慨的地方是,偉大傳奇的作家也不一定要像刻板印象里一樣,有一些神經(jīng)敏感酗酒的文人毛病,最后潦倒死去——她也一樣可以有美滿的婚姻、家庭、名利雙收、最后平靜地離開(kāi),甚至第一個(gè)婚姻的失敗、使其飽受非議的失蹤案這樣的曲折都只增添了偵探小說(shuō)家人生的戲劇性元素;而她的女性身份、護(hù)士藥劑師身份、考古愛(ài)好者身份、獨(dú)身女性旅行者、暢銷書(shū)身份,在各個(gè)領(lǐng)域都可以算作開(kāi)拓者,沒(méi)有比這更圓滿刺激又有價(jià)值的一生了。
印象深刻的新知識(shí)點(diǎn),是她的失蹤失憶案并沒(méi)有一直以來(lái)傳得那么撲朔迷離,她本人和相關(guān)人士早就多次澄清過(guò)是因?yàn)樾睦聿“Y導(dǎo)致的失憶,結(jié)果沒(méi)有人相信,只指責(zé)這是個(gè)拙劣的騙局,只因?yàn)闆](méi)有滿足這些看客想要的戲劇性效果。神游癥是a flight into health,可憐當(dāng)時(shí)她并沒(méi)有得到真正的庇護(hù)所,好在最終最終的結(jié)果是好的。
特別喜歡片中提到失憶的Agatha在療養(yǎng)酒店中看到自己本人失蹤案的新聞報(bào)道,推理出這個(gè)人肯定做了傻事已經(jīng)無(wú)力回天(這個(gè)情節(jié)可太偵探小說(shuō)了哈哈),這未嘗不是在說(shuō),舊的Agatha已經(jīng)脫離了自己并且死去,以后是鈕祜祿·阿加莎了。想起神秘博士那集改編,消失的阿加莎只是又經(jīng)歷了一場(chǎng)奇藝的冒險(xiǎn),以后她的人生只會(huì)更精彩,而那些背叛者的名字早就消失在歷史長(zhǎng)河中了。
很流暢的紀(jì)錄片,就是主觀表達(dá)有時(shí)候有點(diǎn)多,有些探索研究有點(diǎn)武斷,比如阿加莎的醫(yī)師具體是誰(shuí),不過(guò)瑕不掩瑜。
【Cat Among the Pigeons】
She knew she was actually an extraordinary, modern woman whose career was steaming forward but she also sensed society wasn't ready for a woman like her yet, So Agatha would hide her brilliance in plain sight.
She'd used the upheaval of the First world War to her advantage and at this moment she buys the house under her own name during the marriage. We get a glimpse of an Agatha we don't often see, a woman in control of her destiny, a woman unapologetically herself.
【Destination Unknown】
It's fascinating to see Agatha fighting to keep Poirot under her control(away from love story). Made wiser by recent troubles(bereavement, cheated, divorce, lawsuit, press pressure, public censure, insomnia, amnesia, psychotherapy…), emboldened by her independent travel, she was beginning to find the confidence to stand up for herself and her writing.
Miss Marple first appeared as a character in a short story of 1927, The Tuesday Night Club, before emerging as a detective in her own right in 1930's, The Murder at the Vicarage. Now you might think that Miss Marple is a sort of cuddly, tea-drinking old lady. She's actually an independent and quite subversive woman. And she works through feminine intuition. This is how she defines it, ‘’Intuition is like reading a word without having to spell it out. A child can't do that cos a child has little experience. But a grown-up person knows the word because they've seen it often before.’’ She's really talking about life experience. As she says here, ‘’My hobby is and always has been, Human Nature.’’ Now I think it was Agatha's own life experience, this sense that she'd been through trouble and come out stronger, that she was entering into her power, that allowed her to create the rule-breaking Miss Marple. Agatha found a way of combining her new confidence and independence, with the psychological insights from her illness to create the perfect detective. She's one of the great unsung heroes of literature, and one the great women of literature not just crime but everything because she is utterly herself. She's uncompromising but she's gentle and clever. How many other women are the hero of their story at the age of 65, but without it being because they’re somebody's mother. Miss Marple embodied the new Agatha of the late 1920s, determined not to be at anyone's mercy, completely in control of her craft.
Agatha had gone from desperate fugitive to this confident, powerful, independent woman. In a really horrible way I think that the traumatic 1920s had made her stronger. They'd certainly made her into a household name. And I also think, the trouble she'd had made her work better. It made it richer, and darker, and more psychologically interesting. She was ready for a fresh chapter.
【Unfinished Portrait】
Now some people would say that this kind of offensive title is, typical of her class and time, but that's not a get-out-of jail-free card.
Agatha Christie is a woman coming out of that colonial background, she's well read, well educated and she's coming out of a fairly elite class and she's not writing to change the narrative, she's writing so that she's ready for that white audience, that white European, white American audience, and, she is, picking up where they are and not advancing that discussion.——Which is why as a historian I think we have to look at this stuff and appreciate that it was there and to understand how potent it was.——Exactly, we need to understand it in context, knowing that Agatha Christie was not alone in terms of what she was doing. Writers in the United States and elsewhere, here in England, you know everyone was writing in this vein and using this kind of language.(There should be no room for racism.)
She's a good writer, there are some things that aren't acceptable that she wrote. Because if I rule her out I would be ruling out a lot of other writers during that period, there are things you can learn from reading those writers. It is complicated. We can't just, put people into these boxes of good and bad.
Agatha's creation, Miss Marple, the shrewd and observant old lady detective, appears in 12 novels, most of them from the post war years. Now I think the very best Poirot novels are from the twenties and the thirties when Agatha was young. In nineteen-fifty she turned sixty, and from then on she and Miss Marple would get older at the same pace, they'd go through life together, almost as if Christie and Marple were the very same person. Agatha inhabited Miss Marple inside and out. She was so immersed in Marple's stories, that she grabbed anyone she could to help perfect their brilliant plots, including getting her neighbours to act them out.
‘’Goodbye cher amie. They were good days.’’
‘’Sometimes, but not so very often, two people find real love together as we do. We know that what we have cannot perish. For me, you will remain beautiful and precious with the passing of years.’’
娓娓道來(lái)阿加莎克莉絲汀的傳奇人生。有趣的一點(diǎn)是他的主人公絕不陷入愛(ài)情,即使是第一任丈夫沒(méi)有披露出軌前也是。
更多了解了阿加莎的人生軌跡和創(chuàng)作背景,內(nèi)容翔實(shí)考據(jù)細(xì)致,整體推薦。不太喜歡的部分,一是對(duì)個(gè)別名作的劇透環(huán)節(jié),哇,真的是讓人只能慶幸自己讀的早;二是對(duì)于有些事件的觀點(diǎn)和猜測(cè),雖然有可信度但表述未免太過(guò)篤定了。
B站有礦。最喜歡第三集。和第二任丈夫的相遇改變了阿加莎,不變的是她的創(chuàng)作能力和激情。
篇幅短了一些,內(nèi)容夠豐富,配合阿婆自傳可以看影像和解說(shuō)。
目前看了第一集,以前只是知道阿加莎這個(gè)人,這次了解了她的感情史
impressive Queen,驚嘆于失蹤案件,阿婆前半生經(jīng)歷諸多苦難,幸在后半生有Marx為伴,在私人生活重重打擊下依然創(chuàng)造力鮮活,太有生命力了,在錢包中保留愛(ài)人的一封情書(shū)長(zhǎng)達(dá)39年,純情戰(zhàn)士阿加莎xxx
歷史學(xué)家露西更像一個(gè)演員。
少有的相信阿婆是真的創(chuàng)傷失憶,列舉的證據(jù)也較令人信服,沖這點(diǎn)多給一星。三集按照時(shí)間線著重講私人生活和創(chuàng)作的聯(lián)系,喜歡Lucy娓娓道來(lái)一個(gè)“家庭婦女”的悲歡,尤其是婚姻的影響,在作品悄然彰顯,肯定她本身的階級(jí)局限性和作品的跨時(shí)代性,喜歡她和好萊塢談崩是因?yàn)橐诤贤锛印安宀豢梢哉剳賽?ài)”條款(哈哈哈某爵請(qǐng)自打臉)。一個(gè)獲得普世價(jià)值幸福的人,仍然擁有黑暗想象力,實(shí)屬難得。
相對(duì)順利的人生失蹤的十一天終于有了認(rèn)真的解釋
拍的很深入。原來(lái)阿加莎是一個(gè)這么有經(jīng)歷有見(jiàn)識(shí)的女性??吹煤镁o張啊……編的很好很緊湊。她的人生經(jīng)歷真的足夠精彩震撼了。她的藥物學(xué)是在醫(yī)院的藥房學(xué)到的。還學(xué)了藥劑師考試。露西還帶我們看有毒性藥物的土地。紀(jì)錄片非常緊湊有趣。
很有誠(chéng)意的紀(jì)錄片,正是坎坷的經(jīng)歷造就了阿加莎這樣偉大的作者,同時(shí)她也是一個(gè)普通的女子,最后有被阿加莎和第二任丈夫之間的愛(ài)情感動(dòng)到
一位才華橫溢的女作家,從小心翼翼地試探當(dāng)時(shí)的社會(huì)對(duì)一個(gè)聰明女人的容納程度,自己全款買的宅子都要對(duì)外宣稱是和丈夫一起購(gòu)買,還被地產(chǎn)商寫(xiě)合同時(shí)默認(rèn)是“He”。到經(jīng)歷了親人去世、丈夫出軌,精神狀態(tài)差到患上神游癥之后,站起來(lái)掌控自己的人生,獨(dú)自去異國(guó)他鄉(xiāng)旅行,找到了小自己十四歲的真愛(ài),事業(yè)迎來(lái)新的階段,心中的不安全感被事業(yè)的成功、讀者的贊賞、愛(ài)人的陪伴慢慢彌合,成為全球最暢銷的作家。Agatha的靈魂是有重量的,有著超越時(shí)代的智慧和光彩,她的作品也一直與時(shí)俱進(jìn),在那個(gè)對(duì)女性有著諸多限制的年代追尋著最大限度的成功和自由。她的作品與人格魅力歷經(jīng)歲月,閃耀至今。
整體線索、串聯(lián)和燈光鏡頭都非常好看,旁征博引的邀請(qǐng)各種跟阿婆有關(guān)聯(lián)的線索人,而且貌似編劇和策劃都是露西沃斯利女士,真的好厲害好棒
“Sometimes,but not so very often,two people find,real love together as we do.We know that what we have cannot perish.For me,you will remain beautiful and precious with the passing of years.”??
比較獨(dú)到也恰當(dāng)?shù)氖怯昧送评淼氖址ǎ瑢?duì)一些謎題給出了她的結(jié)論,推翻了阿婆在自傳中的一些講法。比如阿婆自稱在職業(yè)上只填寫(xiě)家庭主婦,實(shí)際上她曾在職業(yè)欄填寫(xiě)過(guò)作家。比如阿婆的消失之謎,她也給出了自己的結(jié)論而非如從前的紀(jì)錄片一味渲染。凸顯這部紀(jì)錄片并非吃老本,而是有新的角度。
有些時(shí)候,但不是經(jīng)常發(fā)生,人們會(huì)像我們一樣找到真愛(ài),我們都知道這份感情不會(huì)消逝。在我看來(lái),無(wú)論時(shí)光如何流逝,你依然美麗動(dòng)人,珍貴無(wú)比。
中規(guī)中矩,不是很喜歡。
三集根本講不完阿婆的一生
第一集阿加莎的家庭,婚姻以及創(chuàng)作初期的狀態(tài),阿加莎以及憑借天才的創(chuàng)作(特別是羅杰疑案)贏得了價(jià)值,但傳統(tǒng)價(jià)值觀的女性社會(huì)地位仍然迫使她隱藏在成就之下,自我身份價(jià)值認(rèn)同正干擾著她。第二集婚變的阿加莎制造了一場(chǎng)荒誕且懸疑色彩十足的消失與失憶戲碼,脫單的她更是完成了自我蛻變,變成了自己生活的主宰者。三集迎來(lái)創(chuàng)作爆發(fā)的阿加莎,擁有真愛(ài)與婚姻,關(guān)心民生與社會(huì)的變革,融入作品。紀(jì)錄片以學(xué)者探究的目光挖掘主角的生平和時(shí)代變遷,加之場(chǎng)景的模擬和還原,內(nèi)容和形式都不錯(cuò)。
三集內(nèi)容有點(diǎn)少,為一些傳奇事件提供了注腳,女主持好美~