有很多細(xì)節(jié)沒(méi)大跟上,然后去補(bǔ)了一下課hhhhh,來(lái)自Wikipedia,對(duì)于一些臉盲的地方有幫助。
The movie tells the story of a young Polish girl, Zosia G?owacka, from Volhynia's a village settled by Ukrainians, Poles and Jews.The story begins shortly before the outbreak of World War II in 1939 with the marriage of Zosia's sister to a Ukrainian. During the wedding, Zosia's father decides that she has to marry an older village administrator and a widower, Maciej Skiba, despite her being deeply in love with a young, local Ukrainian boy, Petro. The local Ukrainian population shows a lot of resentment towards Polish officials, as they favor the Polish minority in Volhynia. Because of that, some Ukrainians carry out terrorist attacks against Polish authorities and Ukrainian collaborators. These attacks are met with severe actions from the Polish government, including closing Orthodox churches and the humiliation of the Ukrainian population. Despite that, some parts of the Ukrainian and Polish populations try to reconcile with each other.
When the war begins, Maciej gets conscripted to the Polish Army to fight against the Germans in the September Campaign. When the campaign is lost, Maciej and other survivors try to return to their homes. On their way back, all members of the group, except Maciej, are captured by local Ukrainians, tortured and killed.
Maciej manages to get to the village thanks to disguising himself as a Ukrainian. The village is in the eastern part of Poland, which gets occupied by the Soviet Union, and communist rule is established in the village. The local Ukrainian and Jewish populations co-operate with the Soviet authorities, replacing prewar Polish authorities as governors.
In the meantime, Zosia gets pregnant, most likely by Petro, but wants Maciej to believe that the child is his. As a part of a massive deportation of the Polish population carried out by the Soviets in 1939–1941, Zosia, Maciej and his children, are about to be sent to Siberia or Kazakhstan to do forced labour. Zosia and the children are rescued in the last moment, just as the train is about to depart. Petro bribes the guard with vodka. When they come back to Petro's home, Zosia gets contractions. While she is giving birth to her child, the guard arrives and kills Petro. Zosia then takes care of Maciej's home and children during his absence. The children are sent to a school organized by the Soviets.
The plot then switches to 1941, when the German Army is conquering Volhynia during Operation Barbarossa. The Germans begin to kill the local Jews and organize local police units from Ukrainian collaborators, who actively participate in the Holocaust. However, Zosia and other Ukrainians still try to help the Jews by hiding them in safe places.
In the meantime, Maciej comes back home after he manages to escape deportation. The family tries to organize its life in the changed reality, as the Poles face increased hostility from their Ukrainian neighbours, resulting in an increase of murders of Poles committed by the latter. One day Maciej sets out to the local market despite Zosia's protests motivated by her fearing for his safety. She is proven right, as the other Polish neighbours arrive some days later with Maciej's head cut off.
Zosia tries to get by the best she can while she takes care of the children. However, one day, she defends herself against an attempted rape by a Ukrainian policeman, and the presence of the Jews hidden by her is revealed. The Jews, an old couple and a young unrelated boy, escape and find shelter for the winter in the home of a local Ukrainian, who agrees to help after the Jew promises him a large amount of money. When the Jew's wife dies and winter comes, the Ukrainian demands a payment. When he asees that the Jew cannot pay him, he murders him in the forest. The young Jew is rescued by the Ukrainian's son.
In the summer of 1943, news about the killings committed by Ukrainians spreads among the Poles in the village. At the time, a young Polish man who is seriously injured arrives at Zosia's home. When he recovers, he settles there as it makes Zosia feel safer. He contacts the local Home Army unit, which, by orders of the Polish government in the United Kingdom, does not protect the Poles from Ukrainian attacks but prepares to fight the Germans in the future. When the young man is asked to be a guide for members of the Home Army on the way to a meeting with the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA), Zosia desperately tries to discourage him from going. She failed to stop him. When two members of the Home Army arrive at the meeting, as agreed without weapons, they get surrounded by the UPA soldiers, captured, and then dismembered by horses. The men from the UPA then hunt for the rest of the Home Army group. They find only Zosia's friend, who has escaped and is hiding in a church that is full of Poles. During the ceremony, the Ukrainians enter the church, killing everyone in the way, but Zosia's friend. She runs to the church's tower and somehow survives the attack.
In the meantime, the local Ukrainian population, the former Ukrainian policeman and his friends join the UPA in the forest. They gather and call to eradicate the lands from Poles. There are two ceremonies from the Ukrainian Orthodox priests shown: the first one preaching about loving neighbours and the second one calling to kill all Poles to achieve pure Ukrainian lands at last.
Soon, the first survivors of the pogroms arrive to the village and tell the story of Ukrainian neighbours killing Poles and everybody who protested against the killings. The local Ukrainian village administrator arrives at Zosia's home to ensure her that she and her children can stay at home, as they would not be harmed by their Ukrainian neighbours. Also, other Polish people are reassured about their safety. However, those are only deception tactics to allow Ukrainians to kill as many Poles as possible.
The killings in the village begin at night. Zosia escapes with her child, but as she runs away, she sees Poles being tortured, including pregnant women being stabbed in womb, people getting disemboweled and getting their eyes gouged out. Zosia's stepson is murdered during this massacre. Her stepdaughter, however, is rescued by a Ukrainian peasant. On their way to escape from certain death, Zosia and her child arrive to Petro's previous house, where they get rescued by Petro's mother.
As Zosia runs away with her child from place to place, she encounters the corpses of mutilated Polish infants, women and elderly in every village. In one place, she runs into a unit of the German Army, which saves her from certain death, just moments before Ukrainians are about to kill her and her child. The Germans are astonished at first as to why she walks alongside them, but when they find more and more stacks of murdered Poles on their way, they feel sorry for her and escort her to the place where her sister, Helena, lives. She is welcomed there, as Vasyl, Helena's Ukrainian husband, is friendly to Poles. Zosia hides in their shed with her son. As most of the village's population is already involved in killings, Vasyl's brother tries to convince him to join the nationalists and to kill his Polish wife so that he can save himself and the children. As they wrangle, Vasyl kills his own brother with an axe.
The next night, the whole family is attacked by Poles who seek revenge on Ukrainians. They condemn Helena for living with a Ukrainian. They slaughter her newborn in front of her eyes, kill Vasyl and behead her. Zosia observes everything from the shed. Terrified, she escapes again and is now afraid of both Ukrainians and Poles. She hides in the woods with her son. Subsequent scenes show the UPA rushing through the forest, exultantly celebrating while leading a cart occupied by the Poles who killed Helena's family and other Ukrainians, but now disfigured, mauled and visibly tortured as punishment for the retaliatory attacks. A young, blond man with obscured features places Zosia's son on a horse-drawn cart, before approaching Zosia's resting place in the forest. The film then alternates between shots of an unconscious Zosia on a cart, Zosia and her son walking through a German checkpoint at a bridge, before finally settling on an unconscious Zosia lying on the cart, her son sitting at the front of the wagon with the young man, who looks exactly like Petro, making their way through the wide green fields of Volhynia.
最恐怖的恐怖不是妖魔,不是外星生物,而是人類文明史之間的互相殺伐,長(zhǎng)平之戰(zhàn),揚(yáng)州十日,蒙古入侵,十字軍東征,納粹猶太人,盧旺達(dá)屠殺,南京,紋革等等都是赤裸裸血淋淋的人間地獄,他們能找出各種正當(dāng)理由,資源土地,意識(shí)形態(tài),階級(jí)沖突,宗教信仰,民族仇恨,本片讓我想到零九年烏魯木齊,昨天還是一起吃飯喝茶嘮嗑的鄰居,今天就舉起屠刀向你全家而來(lái),只不過(guò)本片表達(dá)過(guò)于直白殘忍,剝皮,肢解,屠殺孕婦嬰兒,R級(jí)都別想過(guò),諾不是真實(shí)歷史真的會(huì)被介入禁片,看下來(lái)負(fù)能量爆棚,已經(jīng)超過(guò)我的闕值,導(dǎo)致現(xiàn)在寫(xiě)影評(píng)都思維混亂。。
波蘭電影《沃倫》和俄羅斯電影《我們來(lái)自未來(lái)2》,放在一起看有好處。 烏克蘭和白俄羅斯西部有一塊領(lǐng)土,原來(lái)都是俄羅斯沙皇統(tǒng)治,十月革命后的蘇維埃與波蘭戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng),波蘭把這塊地方搶過(guò)去了,有20萬(wàn)平方公里。這塊地方住著烏克蘭人和波蘭人。 二戰(zhàn),德國(guó)入侵波蘭,蘇聯(lián)也趁機(jī)入侵,把這塊地方搶回去了,其中就包括一個(gè)叫沃倫的地方。一些文章常說(shuō)的德國(guó)和蘇聯(lián)夾擊波蘭,實(shí)際蘇聯(lián)不過(guò)是拿回了1920年被波蘭占領(lǐng)的土地。 沃倫這里的烏克蘭人和波蘭人,無(wú)力抗拒強(qiáng)大的德國(guó)人和蘇聯(lián)人,但是互相打來(lái)打去,以及配合德國(guó)欺負(fù)猶太人,還是有兩手。于是有了波蘭人受害的沃倫慘案。 《我們來(lái)自未來(lái)2》,講的是兩個(gè)仇視俄國(guó)人的西部烏克蘭人,經(jīng)歷了時(shí)空穿越,發(fā)現(xiàn)他們與俄羅斯人曾經(jīng)并肩戰(zhàn)斗,抗擊德國(guó)入侵?;氐浆F(xiàn)實(shí)后,改變了對(duì)歷史的看法。 想了解烏克蘭與波蘭、烏克蘭與俄羅斯關(guān)系,看這兩個(gè)電影,會(huì)快一些。
看之前完全不知道是什么類型的片子,一部?jī)蓚€(gè)半小時(shí)的電影抽了半盒黃皖,最后的鏡頭實(shí)在是看的心驚膽戰(zhàn),夾煙的手指都在發(fā)抖。不知道人性怎么可以這樣丑惡!在這之前還對(duì)遍地大長(zhǎng)腿、金發(fā)、美麗、廣袤美麗的農(nóng)莊田野的東歐各種想象,看完之后就覺(jué)得這不是一片化外之地嗎?野蠻、愚昧,不知道對(duì)比納粹,侵華日軍會(huì)怎樣?
對(duì)東歐的歷史一點(diǎn)不通,但是很好奇。電影中的村莊應(yīng)該是烏波交接的地方吧,本來(lái)兩族人和平相處,生活也安逸,可是戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)釋放了仇恨和人本惡,把這美麗的土地化成一片焦土。
現(xiàn)在想想身處和平年代真是幸福了,相比動(dòng)亂的戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)年代哪有人性公平可言,那殘酷血腥的畫(huà)面鏡頭卻是人本身制造的。戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)不是歐洲人獨(dú)有的,我想人類歷經(jīng)幾千年的文明發(fā)展,這樣的戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)不計(jì)其數(shù),發(fā)生在我們這片土地的類似的事情肯定不勝枚舉,說(shuō)近的如南京大屠殺這樣的畫(huà)面就不敢想象,可是中國(guó)關(guān)于這段歷史的電影也不在少數(shù),可是沒(méi)有一個(gè)能有如此深刻的揭露戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)可惡的作品。
巴拉巴拉說(shuō)了沒(méi)頭沒(méi)腦的,還是希望有了解東歐歷史的能給補(bǔ)補(bǔ)腦,網(wǎng)上也沒(méi)有找到相關(guān)的東西。
建議青少年慎觀影,鏡頭太血腥!
求輕噴,處女評(píng)。
切辮切頭,火束活人,墻頭草奪權(quán),伏特加換命,偷雞割臂,桶中斷頭,鄰里兄弟相殘屠殺,讀過(guò)你的詩(shī)歌亦五馬分尸。波蘭姑娘在非常時(shí)期的三個(gè)情人,無(wú)解的極端民族矛盾,太恐怖……導(dǎo)演Wojciech Smarzowski最高杰作
拋開(kāi)劇作層面上的問(wèn)題,這片子在還原歷史方面還是挺震撼的,這位導(dǎo)演對(duì)于還原生活或事件的細(xì)節(jié)一直很嚴(yán)謹(jǐn),這部電影里的屠殺場(chǎng)面,雖然比不上真實(shí)歷史,但絕對(duì)比我們看過(guò)大多數(shù)戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)片震撼,細(xì)節(jié)在于殺人場(chǎng)面的花樣百出。http://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/N1DZZVlWZwBR
4.5 后半段一度干嘔,真實(shí)的極端影像,足以堪稱與《索爾之子》并列的近幾年二戰(zhàn)題材神作。相比烏克蘭土匪,德軍真算文明人了。結(jié)局玩了一手對(duì)臉盲患者不大友好的陰陽(yáng)兩隔套路。
曾經(jīng)好好的民族融合地區(qū)由于戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)政治民族宣傳搞起了無(wú)差別大屠殺 比一切恐怖片都真實(shí) 滿屏幕的血肉模糊 比南京大屠殺更窩心 因?yàn)椴淮嬖谇致园?!看這種電影哭都哭不出 所以我一直說(shuō)人類是世界上最殘忍最沒(méi)人性的生物對(duì)國(guó)人來(lái)說(shuō)的冷門片 大導(dǎo)演殘酷再現(xiàn)歷史的十分之一
民族主義者,慘絕人寰的種族清洗罪行,警鐘長(zhǎng)鳴!
二戰(zhàn)后期烏克蘭人對(duì)波蘭人血腥屠殺,其中還夾雜著蘇聯(lián)人清洗波蘭地主、德國(guó)人滅絕猶太人、波蘭人報(bào)復(fù)烏克蘭人。全片極為血腥極為殘忍,可謂慘不忍睹,只有人類才會(huì)對(duì)同類做出如此可怖勾當(dāng)。一個(gè)強(qiáng)有力的政府可以約束不同種族,防止他們仇殺,一旦政府垮臺(tái),種族仇殺就很難避免,南斯拉夫、盧旺達(dá)都是這樣。
看的是差不多150分鐘的版本(A站還是B站有閹割版本,心理承受能力較弱就去看閹版吧),部分鏡頭會(huì)有不適感,過(guò)于真實(shí)、殘忍,血腥,反人倫。 沃倫大屠殺的遇難人數(shù)超過(guò)八萬(wàn)。
不清楚這段歷史,但并不懷疑人性如此冷酷、卑劣、丑陋。
愿世界和平!真的太慘了,人間煉獄,大過(guò)節(jié)的我為什么要看這么喪的一部電影!
再現(xiàn)戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)殘酷的波蘭電影,B站和諧版,血腥暴力依舊讓我觀影中有很多不適感。烏克蘭民族對(duì)波蘭屠殺也是基于極端的種族主義煽動(dòng)起來(lái)的,人比猛獸更加可怕,因?yàn)閯?dòng)物之間不會(huì)無(wú)故自相殘殺,反而是身為高智商的人類卻有那么多人性的弱點(diǎn),人類是多么可怕的物種!所有還原戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)歷史的電影都堪比恐怖片。
太慘了,戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)陰云與民族主義下的人性黑暗面,屠殺以及各種各樣的屠殺和清洗。人性泯滅后究竟會(huì)有多么殘忍,多么令人反感與厭惡。不忘歷史,珍惜和平,或許是不少人看完該片后的最大感受,畢竟戰(zhàn)爭(zhēng)帶給人們的傷痛太大了?!皷|部的波蘭人被屠殺兩次,先是被斧子砍,第二次卻是死于沉默。”3.6
還是形式大于內(nèi)容了吧,不得不說(shuō)剪輯很混亂,零碎無(wú)厘頭的鏡頭,加上女主活不起的表情,讓我無(wú)數(shù)次放棄觀看
敘事基本上是徹底失敗的,凌亂的剪輯更是雪上加霜。唯一值得稱道的就是這個(gè)無(wú)比凝重的題材,可惜這么拍真是暴殄天物。
寧做太平犬,不做亂離人。還能說(shuō)什么呢?一切堅(jiān)韌,勇敢,果決,在大歷史面前根本不值一提。巨大的輪子碾過(guò),你連粉末都不剩。
8 歷史反復(fù)證明 民族混居與信仰沖突的地區(qū)積攢的矛盾一旦爆發(fā) 后果將是萬(wàn)劫不復(fù)的人性深淵;波蘭和烏克蘭 兩個(gè)夾雜在德國(guó)和野蠻俄狗之間的悲情國(guó)家無(wú)法擺脫的命運(yùn) 相比波蘭 烏克蘭更不走運(yùn) 今日烏之現(xiàn)狀能看做是歷史的報(bào)復(fù)嗎;德軍:早知道你們斯拉夫人內(nèi)斗這么狠 干嘛還親自動(dòng)手
唯一想說(shuō)的,是這片子對(duì)臉盲癥太不友好了??
很多人把這類悲劇歸結(jié)為民族、宗教、意識(shí)形態(tài)等等紛爭(zhēng),事實(shí)上問(wèn)題的根源是無(wú)政府狀態(tài),沒(méi)有制約獸性的暴力機(jī)構(gòu),人類會(huì)爆發(fā)出最原始的最大的惡...
結(jié)局只能說(shuō)是女主自己的想像了,她的倖存不代表她能再“正?!被钕氯?。烏克蘭人當(dāng)年對(duì)波蘭人的無(wú)差別虐殺是基本完整呈現(xiàn)在本片當(dāng)中,每件虐殺過(guò)程都是有記錄在案的事實(shí)。而女主姐姐一家的遭遇也表示波蘭人的事後報(bào)復(fù)也清除了最後一丁點(diǎn)烏克蘭少數(shù)好人原本的民族共存努力,此片極度令人不適。
真正的恐怖片
片里的波蘭人也是倒了血霉了,熬過(guò)了蘇聯(lián)紅軍,熬過(guò)了德國(guó)納粹,以為這下終于結(jié)束了,卻被烏克蘭民族主義者血洗了。最后幾十分鐘的大屠殺真是得捂著心臟看才行。