水向低處流，人向高處走。

如果付出同樣的勞動，而有著不同的生活水準，誰不想往更好的國家去？

但如果不是在原來的祖國生存不下去，又有誰會想要去移民？

社會是分層的。既需要有知識的醫(yī)生、律師，也需要有愿意從事勞務(wù)工作的洗衣工、環(huán)衛(wèi)工。所以既需要引進具有創(chuàng)新能力的高科技人才，也需要在農(nóng)忙時節(jié)引進大量的勞務(wù)工人。移民政策就是為了調(diào)節(jié)這些不同的需求。

影片最后入籍歸化宣誓的一場戲，讓我想到很多。

如果世界上的國家不是按民族來劃分，而是按不同的宗教信仰或不同的政治傾向來劃分，每個國家都有自己不同的理念和原則，你加入這個國家，愿意在這個國家工作和生活，你就要認同它的理念，并宣誓效忠于這個國家，否則就離開它，移居到自己喜歡的國家去。

無論基督教、伊斯蘭教、儒教，無論納粹的國家社會主義、凱恩斯的國家資本主義、哈耶克的自由市場經(jīng)濟、蘇維埃的共產(chǎn)主義，都劃分在一定的地域內(nèi)做自己的社會實驗，讓民眾自己來用腳投票。然后按預(yù)先制定的規(guī)則，當人口占土地的比例低于某個數(shù)值時，這個國家就可以被宣布為自然消亡。

哈哈哈！這樣多好！

電影的前半段還是挺不錯的，基本上交代了每一個移民者的處境，每一個也合情合理。后面的交代感覺沒什么意思了。猶太人蒙混過關(guān)，澳大利亞美女遣返，中東小女孩被遣返，我以為她要真的搞自殺式襲擊了，墨西哥媽媽死在尋子路上，韓國人被伊朗帥哥救贖，但是伊朗家族一家即便都已經(jīng)入籍了，但家族依然保守。

可能電影只是想客觀的描述真實世界里最常見的結(jié)局沒有啥象征。但是觀眾看來是想入美國籍，要不就是有錢，要不就是運氣爆表，美國不養(yǎng)窮人，不講親情，沒有言論自由，即便入籍，伊朗人還是伊朗人，保守家族還是看不慣美二代的潮妹。

這就對了，本就沒有天堂，無論到哪，物競天擇的自然法則也不會有變，美國更加如此。至于要說這樣對不對，那自然不符合我們社會主義國家公平正義的價值觀，為什么美國能成為其他國家和地區(qū)人民想要移民去的地方，在疫情后時代，如果你還認為是他制度先進，科技發(fā)達，其他地區(qū)的政府不作為，那只能說各有各的世界觀了。

想起姜文的北京人在紐約，作為移民主題的作品，可能更能讓我們看到中國人在那個時代的欲愁酸楚。

Although these people have their various flaws and dark sides, these negative aspects make them appear more real. They are just some people like you and me, trying to pursue a better life by immigrating. In any case, in exchange for the legal residence of the “Great World” pass, they are struggling between moral and immoral, loyalty and betrayal, hell and heaven, and desperation and justice.

Here comes an interesting question: is person a person? When you are born, you are British person, American person, Indian person, Chinese person, etc. If we remove the label “American”, you are just a “person”. If we plus “America”, you have an extra credit to mark yourself. However, at the same time, you are also one step far away from the essence of “person” which can be divided by the nation labels. The conflicts between religious traditions and moral liberation, economic protection and cheap labor force, integrity police and corrupt officials are all happening under the US national flag. Perhaps the country is only a concentrated expression of all these contradictions. Either people choose coming here or leaving here, they are just choosing something called “hope”.

The United States is a place where many people want to go. Before they get the green card, everyone has to worry about being forced to leave someday. While looking for jobs, salaries, medical cares, etc., whether or not you have a green card have a huge disparity. At the end of the film, the lucky people who vowed to become new citizens of the United States under the giant Stars and the Mexican female corpse who died on the road of smuggling formed a series of shocking and contrastive pictures. At that moment, I felt my body is trembling. I realize that freedom, vitality and creativity will only be fostered in a tolerant place, and only an open society can be confident, attractive and cohesive. Please don’t forget that immigrants have always contributed to the prosperity of US powers. If the Statue of Liberty is their last spiritual belief, please don't let these people who worship her devoutly become the sacrifice and die in the path of pursuing their dreams.