Controversial Pakistani cleric Maulana Aziz, linked to the Taliban, declares jihad against the government to impose sharia law. The government retaliates by destroying his seminary, killing his mother, brother, his only son and 150 students. The film follows charming yet menacing Maulana Aziz on his personal quest to create an Islamic utopia, which causes the country to implode. The Red Mosque has students allied with ISIL, and strong ties to the Taliban. We meet two Red Mosque students whose paths diverge: Talha, 12, leaves his moderate Muslim family to study to be a jihadi preacher. Zarina, also 12, escapes her madrassa and joins a normal school. Her education is threatened by frequent Taliban attacks on schools like her own. In December, 2014, the Taliban massacred 132 schoolchildren in Peshawar, outraging Pakistan's moderate majority. Aziz's longtime opponent, education reformer Pervez Hoodbhoy joins the re-energized anti-extremist movement. Throughout the film, he passionately opposes Aziz on television and public forums. With the tide turning against the cleric, Pervez is determined to see Aziz put in jail. Intimate and brutally honest, AMONG THE BELIEVERS offers rare insight into the ideological battle shaping Pakistan and the Muslim world. Pakistan's notorious cleric Maulana Aziz, with links to Taliban, declares jihad against the government to impose sharia law. This sparks a bloody war and causes the country to implode. Along with Aziz's quest, the film charts the coming-of-age stories of his two students who are trapped in this ideological war.
只有滿屏的恐懼
任何宗教的原教旨主義者都會(huì)變得越來越極端,這種意識(shí)形態(tài)又很容易在所謂的“教育”中reproduce,挺絕望的。
道德,知識(shí),這些是在人類社會(huì)中指導(dǎo)我們?nèi)绾螢槿诵惺碌穆窐?biāo),他們保留我們絕大部分的自由,在歷史的長(zhǎng)河中順應(yīng)時(shí)代發(fā)展不斷取精去粕,最終形成法律等規(guī)定我們言行的社會(huì)規(guī)范。而宗教從誕生起便不加區(qū)分的強(qiáng)迫規(guī)范人們的言行舉止,積累了一千余年的糟粕到今天仍然使用從而引發(fā)貧窮與暴力的惡性循環(huán)。
Religion真是毒瘤啊
挺令人深思的一部作品,有深層次的意義在里面。
貧窮是很多問題無法理清的死結(jié)
社會(huì)環(huán)境、家庭教育什么樣,人就長(zhǎng)成什么樣,是人類大腦的常態(tài)。三觀定型之后,在面對(duì)『你為什么這么做?』『為什么會(huì)這樣想?』的疑問時(shí),人們往往不是困惑就是憤怒?!簺]有為什么,就該這樣做』——這種可怕的定勢(shì)反饋,其實(shí)并不專屬于極端穆斯林,而是屬于從不問自己為什么、只憑本能行事的所有人。
伊斯蘭極端主義的問題始終都還是需要伊斯蘭內(nèi)部開始正視以及自己解決。我們始終是outsider,沒辦法也沒有能力解決他們內(nèi)部的問題。這部紀(jì)錄片正好提供了這樣一個(gè)視角。
不錯(cuò)
The head of The Red Mosque:"If you don't agree with us, then arrest us, shoot us. If you want to change us, then forget it." Madrassh的所有費(fèi)用全免而公立學(xué)校的學(xué)費(fèi)很貴,有些家庭連孩子的溫飽都不能解決會(huì)把孩子送去Madrassh,家長(zhǎng)也不知道Madrassh里教的內(nèi)容;如果孩子兩個(gè)學(xué)校都不去,男孩會(huì)成為勞工,女孩會(huì)被嫁出去。從2007年7月政府發(fā)起攻擊開始,巴基斯坦因兩方不斷的沖突斗爭(zhēng)變得四分五裂。
觸目驚心,這些孩子們從這樣的學(xué)校出來后會(huì)成為怎樣的人做怎樣的事,光是想個(gè)開頭就渾身冒冷汗了
僅僅是展示言行和所處的環(huán)境,便足夠了,甚至不用太多的旁白。
sff
No
任何只崇拜一本書,一個(gè)人的世界都是邪惡的,并且是源頭……
目前為止最好的伊斯蘭極端主義紀(jì)錄片之一:在貧窮和暴力循環(huán)中,每個(gè)人都是受害者。更重要的是,清晰地呈現(xiàn)給大家,這個(gè)封閉的死結(jié)根本是西方世界不論采取什么態(tài)度都不可能解開的。就連本地人也已經(jīng)試了將近70年,仍然沒有解決辦法。
2019/02/04
比什么鬼白盔高得不知道哪里去了
厲害
關(guān)于巴基斯坦“紅色清真寺”組織的紀(jì)錄片只要人人都能吃得飽飯,都能接受基礎(chǔ)的教育??植乐髁x就失去了生長(zhǎng)的土壤。我們國(guó)家關(guān)于新疆的政策是非常正確的??