猜你喜歡
劇照
詳細(xì)劇情
長(zhǎng)篇影評(píng)
1 ) A Letter to Joe
紀(jì)錄片最后的信
Dear Joe,
This is the hardest thing to do, why is this so hard. I mean you are me, or rather, you were me, so why does this feel impossible. There are things you need to know, light to shine into the darkness, truths to replace those lies. I know what has happened, and what is about to happen to you, and in this regard, you actually know more than me. There are still things I don’t know that you do, memories I have not yet remembered, and yet still weigh upon my mind. You’ll lock away these memories in the days to come, you’ll be trapped, pushed back and silenced, but you do it as the only way you see to survive. It’s taken me nearly 40 years to understand, although time continues to march forward, I continue to be anchored in the past, by you, to you and with you.
And as you repressed the memories of what happened to us, I trapped you, along with those terrible times, deep in the dark places in my mind. How awful it is to be locked inside, to be both the prisoner and jailer, how awful it is to not just be silenced in the present, but also to be the originator of that silence in the past.
It’s an incredible sacrifice you’re about to make, but you need to know that it was the right thing to do. And that, with time, you’re finally free. And as you recover, you even find your voice. Your sacrifice has saved me.
You are the fire that burns within, no longer with hatred and self-disgust, but with the need to share with others, and help lead guys like you to a better place. It was you that chose to keep living each day, it was you that chose to get out of bed. In short, you chose to live and to love, and in return, you chose to be loved.
Remember your superman sheets and curtains? Superman was your hero, he was not human, how many times did you feel like you were not human? You wanted so badly to be him, to be anyone other than you. You wanted to fight for truth and justice, he was your epic hero. Well, that’s exactly what you have become. You entered the battle of your life, and have gone on to use those tears, fears and pain, to reach out to and better understand other boys in pain, who struggle through their own epic battles, you became an advocate for youth, and fight, in a very real way for truth and justice.
I hope the strength you showed is rewarded with peace and contentment. Make no mistake, you’re the epic hero in the story of us.
換了一種動(dòng)機(jī)使用《殺戮演繹》，但呈現(xiàn)出來(lái)的依舊更多是傷害，而非療愈。當(dāng)然，人物的崩潰可能主要還是因?yàn)樽吩V時(shí)效。
心理學(xué)的戲劇治療還是挺有意思的，真希望自己能體驗(yàn)一次。關(guān)于本片，敘事節(jié)奏和結(jié)構(gòu)無(wú)法完全吸引我，看了一般棄劇。
這是用魔法打敗魔法的治療方法嗎？讓他們通過(guò)拍攝過(guò)程，直面小時(shí)候受到的侵害，同命運(yùn)的大家一起面對(duì)，最后角色扮演，真能奏效嗎？這是男權(quán)社會(huì)的方法，通過(guò)角色扮演讓他們成為有力量、有權(quán)利的當(dāng)年的神職人員，真的可以嗎？把積怨發(fā)泄給那個(gè)小男孩兒？這一點(diǎn)我表示懷疑。還有天主教會(huì)的性侵案子，都是針對(duì)的小男孩。難道那么整齊，教士們都是同性戀？沒(méi)有小女孩作為受害者？
戲劇療法重現(xiàn)噩夢(mèng)現(xiàn)場(chǎng)，創(chuàng)作中釋放升華
。。
最后一封a letter to Joe寫得太好了，瞬間升華紀(jì)錄片
過(guò)于強(qiáng)調(diào)戲劇的治療，雖然依舊拍出了如何從陰影中治愈，而且通過(guò)這種戲劇化的表演，模糊現(xiàn)實(shí)與記憶的交界，有一種更沉浸式的體驗(yàn)，但我依舊不喜歡這部紀(jì)錄片過(guò)于執(zhí)著于形式，而不能夠深入受害者
比《感謝上帝》好太多，這種太真實(shí)的紀(jì)錄片真的好讓人心碎，終于看到一部不是立場(chǎng)先行的紀(jì)錄片了。
介乎周浩《孤注》和奧本海默《殺戮演繹》的紀(jì)錄和表演屬性之間。教會(huì)性侵受害者團(tuán)體，抱團(tuán)取暖，療愈自己的方式，竟然是以彼此扮演施害人、并找職業(yè)小演員方式，通過(guò)實(shí)景戲劇、個(gè)人片段劇情片并最終目標(biāo)確鑿的紀(jì)錄片方式，在共同傷痛折磨和共同創(chuàng)作目標(biāo)激勵(lì)下，完成了這個(gè)獨(dú)特作品。
這種cos場(chǎng)景體察心境的診療方式，海林格直呼內(nèi)行。片子整體偏治愈系，不太好入戲。
見識(shí)了一下戲劇治療，這倒是一種直面恐懼的方式，重現(xiàn)噩夢(mèng)記憶，用這樣的方式去袒露內(nèi)心，是一種情緒的宣泄，能不能治愈就不知道了，但能從幾個(gè)參與的幸存者身上看到最真實(shí)的人類情緒，他們有這份勇氣站出來(lái)很了不起。
手段都是次要的，重要的是壞人得到懲罰和受害者能得到幫助、走出陰影、從此行走在陽(yáng)光下。片子有點(diǎn)迷失在戲劇治療之中，缺少了一點(diǎn)人文關(guān)懷和情感力量。
如何去治愈，如何去戰(zhàn)勝，如何去對(duì)抗時(shí)間…因?yàn)闅W容和《感謝上帝》珠玉在前，這里的切入以及背景交代算不得突破；并且反而會(huì)因?yàn)橹貜?fù)敘述和各種新聞曝光也無(wú)濟(jì)于事，更感無(wú)力，無(wú)從進(jìn)行。但相較于只是提供事實(shí)，讓對(duì)象追問(wèn)與坦陳；打破劇情化表演與紀(jì)實(shí)交代的界限，卻真正試著走進(jìn)所有人的心里。鏡頭不分內(nèi)外，用更壓制與沉浸的方式直擊創(chuàng)傷；依然生動(dòng)，并且充滿力量。致勇氣，致堅(jiān)持。
7/10
#SLIFF 戲劇療法作為一種成本高昂執(zhí)行復(fù)雜的心理治療范式，不過(guò)是為電影提供戲劇化的呈現(xiàn)。而心理創(chuàng)傷幸存者們的內(nèi)心療愈過(guò)程，在普遍意義上打動(dòng)人心，才是電影所要表達(dá)的內(nèi)核。
他幾十年后流淚的樣子，是他十歲的樣子。那個(gè)小男孩永遠(yuǎn)被困在凌辱痛苦無(wú)助中，這太不公平。為什么會(huì)有人這樣對(duì)待一個(gè)孩子，不得好死。
上完心理劇課過(guò)來(lái)看這一片子，對(duì)于戲劇可以治療感到十分驚喜。片中主要展示了前期置景的過(guò)程，對(duì)于治療過(guò)程的展示較少，感覺(jué)沒(méi)有很好的講述戲劇治療整個(gè)事情。
80分。結(jié)構(gòu)散亂。
即使不意外依然震驚於那種創(chuàng)傷的巨大與恐怖, 這些人其實(shí)都已經(jīng)建立起某種強(qiáng)悍的心理素質(zhì)來(lái)面對(duì)了, 才能真的走在一起拍這紀(jì)錄片, 而彼此幫助為此努力都很令人動(dòng)容, 拍出來(lái)的戲劇治療內(nèi)容有些也很酷//不再為每個(gè)人的地獄刨根究底, 但更坦然地與之凝視, 既不正義也不絕望, 也許瞎忙一場(chǎng)又如何才是紀(jì)錄片的真實(shí)吧
治療方法缺乏真正的理論基礎(chǔ)，戲劇治療師的眼神、氣質(zhì)顯然也不具備真正的智慧和理解力，就像個(gè)技校老師，而不是導(dǎo)師，我相信她能教小孩做手工學(xué)打字，可沒(méi)法相信她能開導(dǎo)學(xué)生，連教繪畫都不行，沒(méi)靈氣，死板。心理治療的公式是追溯創(chuàng)傷場(chǎng)景，可是讓受害人扮演施害者，而且是在項(xiàng)目最初的第一天，這太草率了。這也讓人理解這股政治正確的風(fēng)潮為什么會(huì)讓黑人扮演奴隸主，好像直接倒換身份就能解決問(wèn)題，不知道該說(shuō)天真還是猴急毛躁。