曾幾何時,美國號稱擁有世界上最好的公立教育系統(tǒng),但在過去的三十多年里,雖然政客們不斷強調(diào)要改善弊端叢生的教育系統(tǒng),可是孩子們的教育情況始終沒有任何改觀,反而呈現(xiàn)令人擔憂的前景。這些出生在普通家庭的孩子,多在閱讀和數(shù)學方面存在著巨大的障礙,且平均水平大大低于地球上其他發(fā)達國家。甚至有的高中成為了臭名昭著的輟學工廠,無數(shù)少年過早進入社會,國家在一名囚徒身上的花費遠遠高于花在一名學生身上的經(jīng)費。美國當前的公立教育系統(tǒng),呈現(xiàn)著本末倒置的吊詭局面。是該積極行動起來,一掃這一領(lǐng)域中的弊端,還是呆呆坐在地上,等待超人的出現(xiàn)?
本片榮獲2010年圣丹斯電影節(jié)觀眾獎最佳紀錄片獎。
let them shine~ let them shine~ “I wanna go to college because I want my kids to live in a better place” Being a teacher means 你承載著全社會的夢想 這個職業(yè)太重要 美國意識到了 我突然想起一件事情 有個舍友跟過我和另外一個舍友說 想不明白為什么你們會想當老師 碰到調(diào)皮的孩子不會很生氣嗎 另外一個舍友回答 她隨緣渡人 我說 難道你不會好奇他們?yōu)槭裁磿B(yǎng)成這種性格嗎 不好奇education到底怎么樣影響人 怎么樣把人影響好嗎 我真的是strongly believe in 我要做的不僅僅是present the knowledge 更是 guide them through their lives Besides 我弟弟半年前也經(jīng)歷過“l(fā)ottery” harsh for me to 看到他們present抽獎現(xiàn)場 他們1 in 10 或者5 都keep fingercrossed through the whole process 我們呢 我們呢 1 in 5000?我們的情況 比美國更迫切 to change the education system to make good teachers and then to have a better education system for our kids
這部紀錄片是通識課的老師推薦的 看完后真的感觸頗多
教育真的很重要 公平的教育更重要 “運氣”是不公平的 最后的抽簽情節(jié)真的給我看哭了TT 沒被選上的孩子會不會從這里就覺得“哦 我是不會被選中的人”呢 母愛真的很偉大TT
KIPP 和 the baby college真的好厲害 很有開創(chuàng)性 讓人們意識到每一個孩子都能通過受教育而變成更好的人 包括那些貧困、家庭有問題的“差孩子”
官僚體制和教師工會確實是阻礙發(fā)展的絆腳石 下放過多的自主權(quán)也是不行的 教師工會保護的是一群不上進的老師.. 這里面的關(guān)系錯綜復雜 所以真的很佩服Michalle Rhee 好有魄力
希望以后自己可以成為一名優(yōu)秀的老師!
自勉!!
This semester , I took a course called looking at American education through movies . At the first class , our teacher showed us a documentary called waiting for superman . It gives me a lot new ideas about American and American education after watching it.
Waiting for "Superman" is a 2010 American documentary film directed by Davis Guggenheim and produced by Lesley Chilcott . By following five students , the film criticizes the American public education system : inequity of education resources , teachers do not take work seriously , bloated public education system …These problems have led to a decline in the quality of education in the United States : the grades of reading and math have not improved since 1970s , a lot students can not be admitted into university , increase of crime rate …
The film changes my view of America . I have not been to America before , the way I know about America just is watching American movies . especially Hollywood movies . In my old view , America is the best nation in the world , it has the best university , people all over the world want to go to America . It seems that everything is perfect , and there is no issues in America. But the film tells me that problems are everywhere , no matter in America .
I got known that American education and Chinese education have both Commonality and differences . America and China both have public education system , which is free for every students . However , America private education is well developed , while Chinese is not . The best schools in America are private schools . But on the contrary , the best schools in China are established by government. Perhaps it is may because of the culture and history . Besides , the education system of America and China is same . A kid will get into primary school when he grows up , and then junior school , high school . When he Reach the appropriate level , he will be admitted into a university . That is same as China . Another difference I find is that assessment method between America and China is different . We Chinese students have to take gaokao before we get into university , and there are six course exams in gaokao . But students in America is examined by reading and math ability .
The above is my observation . All in all , education is a very important part to the development of human being . As the end of the film said , good education is not from superman , it is from everyone of us . We should take it seriously and take actions . By the way , if there is any chance , I would like to go to America to experience American education by myself .
2018.6
無話可說。。。。真是需要多少幸運,我們才走到今天這一步。。。
圣丹斯電影節(jié)觀眾獎最佳紀錄片獎
美國公立中小學教改(有錢人都去上私立了喲):教師工會成教改阻礙(廢除終身教職失敗,只獎不罰亦失敗)、搖號錄取法(當是買車牌啊?中國教育雖然糟糕但我上學時跨區(qū)擇校是靠考分)、提高分數(shù)似乎還是得加長學時?蓋茨說數(shù)學、科學、工程人才是發(fā)展經(jīng)濟的命脈——耳熟么?學好數(shù)理化走遍天下都不怕!
紀錄片揭示了美國的公立教育現(xiàn)狀,由于教師工會的存在,美國公立學校的教師也跟中國的一樣變得尸位素餐、坐吃等死,誤人子弟,雖然有些教師努力改變現(xiàn)狀,卻有心無力。
等待被叫號的時候,真的連心都是被揪著的。
小結(jié)一下:被釆訪的學生家庭中一個亞裔都沒有;美國公立教育質(zhì)量差,為什么說差,中國的也差呀?但是我們沒花他們那么多錢、每個人頭上
立意很好,內(nèi)容無聊,論點有誤
他們說的解決方法怎么像應試教育唉
同樣的問題中國也存在
我們不能一起抱著滾進火坑里把自己埋起來一起窒息。哎~這叫吾國的教育情何以堪??!
難得一見主流紀錄片對工會開炮,可惜如今7年過去,教師工會依然是阻礙教育質(zhì)量提高的罪魁禍首。Charter School好,學券制好,School Choice好
根據(jù)地域來劃分學區(qū)有其好處,但是學生流通的不暢性是其最大的弊端,為何不向中國學習通過考試選拔呢,不過這又將變成一場考試大戰(zhàn),學生淪為考試的奴隸,在我們?yōu)槊绹駠u的同時,我們還是不要忘記,現(xiàn)在依然是美國的教育體系培養(yǎng)出了那么多諾貝爾獎獲得者
一直搞不懂這種論文體的紀錄片到底算不算紀錄片。
美國也不是那么的天堂啊,一心想著要去美國讀書的我其實并不了解他們的教育體系。
精英的成功建筑在多數(shù)人的失敗上?
他們在討論教育公平,我們在追求馬太效應。
國家在一名囚徒身上的花費遠遠高于花在一名學生身上的經(jīng)費??吹搅艘粋€國家在教育體制改革上的無奈~~
所以說教育難題舉世矚目,但話說回來,人家好歹還有個超人可以YY,我們捏?
很到位,同時也有戲劇張力的紀錄片。
美國也不全是天堂,窮人在哪里都是身處地獄。